But even if you should suffer for the sake of righteousness, you are blessed. And do not fear their intimidation, and do not be troubled, but sanctify Christ as Lord in your hearts, always being ready to make a defense to everyone who asks you to give an account for the hope that is in you yet with gentleness and reverence; and keep a good conscience so that in the thing in which you are slandered, those who revile your good behavior in Christ will be put to shame.  1 Peter 3: 14-16

Apologetic Report - The Underground Thomist
Sunday, 19 March 2017 16:00

Thomas Aquinas’s Virtue Ethics

Written by

image

 

My new book, Commentary on Thomas Aquinas’s Virtue Ethics,is coming out from Cambridge University Press on April 30, and you can preorder right here.  I wish the cover design were finished, because the cover image is lovely (nope, it’s not the one above).

By the way, my...

Read more

Sunday, 12 March 2017 16:00

A Question for the Teachers of the Church

Written by

image

 

Why doesn’t the social witness of the Church have more influence than it does?  With respect, I suggest that perhaps one reason is that sometimes those who represent the Church speak as though they don’t believe her social doctrine.

Case in point:  The social doctrine of...

Read more

Sunday, 05 March 2017 15:00

An Answer to My Question

Written by

imageA reader protests:

This last blog [of yours] concerning the recent election seems little more than a petty swipe at the community to which you once belonged.  It is an act of discord being neither an act of unity or of fellowship.

For myself regarding this election, Trump is a base and...

Read more

Sunday, 26 February 2017 15:00

A Question for Evangelicals

Written by

imageShortly after the election, I wrote that the president-elect would do well to remember that his election represented not so much a “Yes” to him, as a “No” to what preceded him.  Perhaps I overstated the point, because some did say “Yes” to him.

In...

Read more

Monday, 20 February 2017 15:00

Castle Archives

Written by

image

 

Sorry, no new post until next week.  In the meantime, some readers might enjoy perusing old posts in the castle archives.

Subscribe

 

Authors: jbudziszewski...

Read more

Sunday, 12 February 2017 23:00

Is Toleration a Virtue?

Written by

image

Question:

I've been back and forth in a discussion of the suggestion that tolerance is a virtue.  A speaker to our community said "Tolerance is not a virtue" -- by which I understood him to mean, and readily affirmed with him, that the cultural mentality that suggests simple co-existence with...

Read more

Wednesday, 08 February 2017 23:00

Couldn’t Resist

Written by

image

 

What did Macbeth say say when he saw Birnam Wood advancing on Dunsinane?

“Cheese it!  The copse!”

Subscribe

 

Authors: jbudziszewski...

Read more

Sunday, 05 February 2017 23:00

So Many Things

Written by

image

 

People of my age often say "Kids are so much smarter these days than we were.  They know so many things that we didn’t."

They do know more “things,” just because they have the new media.  But that sort of knowledge is all breadth, with no depth.

Imagine trying to see...

Read more

Sunday, 29 January 2017 23:00

Interiority

Written by

image

 

Modern thinkers suppose that only a mind, mysteriously shut into itself yet somehow conscious of an “outside” world that it can never reach, can be truly said to have an interior life. Because of this prejudice, we view all things other than minds as mere mechanisms, assemblies of...

Read more

Sunday, 22 January 2017 23:00

Can Politics Be Reduced to a Science?

Written by

image

 

I don’t think much of David Hume’s philosophy, but he was an astute observer of government.  If he was right in his famous 1742 essay “That Politics May Be Reduced to a Science,” then the prospects of applying the sort of science he had in mind to our own country...

Read more

Sunday, 15 January 2017 23:00

Spoiler Alert

Written by

image

I had not learned until recently that George Orwell, the author of several dystopian stories, had also reviewed C.S. Lewis’s supernatural thriller, That Hideous Strength.  Though he conceded that the novel was worth reading (and it is), he finished by complaining that supernatural...

Read more

Wednesday, 11 January 2017 23:00

The Revenge of Conscience Is Now an Ebook

Written by

image

My book The Revenge of Conscience: Politics and the Fall of Manis now available electronically, as a Kindle.  Among other things, that makes it much cheaper.  Here is the link.

Subscribe

Authors:...

Read more

Sunday, 08 January 2017 23:00

What it Really Means to Be Great

Written by

image

In a conversation with one of the Athenian bully boys, Socrates suggested that what makes statesmen great is not whether they are good or bad at doing things and at giving the people what they want -- but whether, by their conduct and rhetoric, they leave the people better or worse than they found...

Read more

Sunday, 01 January 2017 23:00

Trusting in Princes

Written by

image

 

Commenting on CBS This Morningon the end of her husband’s term of office and the election of a rival, the outgoing First Lady said “We feel the difference now.  See, now, we’re feeling what not having hope feels like.”

It is said that in Washington, she and her...

Read more

Saturday, 24 December 2016 23:00

The Infant’s Voice

Written by

imageYesterday I displayed a few gems from a Christmas Vigil sermon by Bernard of Clairvaux.  These are from a pair of his sermons for Christmas Day.  I have taken a few liberties with the translation, which is a bit dated.

Christ is born in a stable, and lies in a...

Read more

Friday, 23 December 2016 23:00

More Than Long Ago

Written by

image

 

These rubies are from a Christmas Vigil sermon by Bernard of Clairvaux.

+++  +  +++

Let no one be so indevout, so ungrateful, so irreligious, as to say:  This is nothing new; it was heard long ago; Christ was born long ago.  I answer:  Yes, long ago and before long ago.

N...

Read more

Monday, 19 December 2016 23:00

Off With Their Heads!

Written by

image

Two small errors turned up in the hardcover edition of my Commentary on Thomas Aquinas’s Treatise on Law. Although they were corrected in the paperback, a reader suggests that I post the corrections here too.  Good idea.

The first error is rather funny:  On the cover, the word C...

Read more

Sunday, 11 December 2016 23:00

The Object of Uttermost Longing

Written by

imageQuery:

What would you say is the single most compelling, prima facie argument for God?

Reply:

The argument I find most compelling is sometimes called the Argument from Desire.

At the very beginning of the Summa Theologiae, St. Thomas says that “To know that God exists in a general and confused...

Read more

Sunday, 04 December 2016 23:00

Full Circle

Written by

image

Men think they may do as they please.

In order to limit them, among other things the law of Moses prohibits disproportionate revenge:  One may take an eye for an eye and a tooth for a tooth, but not a life for an eye or a limb for a tooth.

To men who have been successfully shaped by that wise...

Read more

Sunday, 27 November 2016 23:00

Mean Moralists

Written by

image

I am glad to say that after receiving my response, this fellow made a gracious reply.

Query:

I've begun your guide because even as an atheist I believed in abiding universals and liked Epictetus and Cicero.

I have a complaint with you. I've known women who had abortions who were deeply mournful but...

Read more

Sunday, 20 November 2016 23:00

A Little Talk

Written by

image

 

This is the text of my acceptance talk for the Pope Pius XI Award for Contributions to the Building Up of a True Catholic Social Science, at October’s annual meeting of the Society of Catholic Social Scientists.  I had hesitated to post it, but my advisors think it would be...

Read more

Sunday, 13 November 2016 23:00

Advice for the President-Elect

Written by

image

I stoutly hope that I am wrong about how the president-elect will govern.  He has made several appropriate gestures, and he did not use his victory speech to boast and bluster, as he might have.

However, he seems to be laboring under a misconception.  He thinks he won.

No, the other...

Read more

Tuesday, 08 November 2016 23:00

Good news. One of them lost.

Written by

image

Authors: jbudziszewski...

Read more

Sunday, 06 November 2016 23:00

Have Mercy

Written by

image

One of the principal forms of political discussion in the American colonies in the years before independence was what were called “election day sermons.”  The term “election day” did not mean the day voters went to the polls to choose delegates, as with us, but the day...

Read more

Tuesday, 01 November 2016 23:00

What Words Mean

Written by

image

Liberalism is said to mean believing in liberality, which is generosity.  Though generosity is a real virtue, it lies between opposite vices.  The interesting question, then, is not whether you are in favor of liberality.  Instead let us ask:  How do you recognize and avoid...

Read more

Page 1 of 9